The Hunt
They Wanted a Two-Bedroom in Queens, With Room to Grow, for Less Than $400,000
Seeking to put down roots in their community, a pair of newlyweds searched the co-ops of Jackson Heights and Elmhurst. Here’s what they found.
Five years ago, Bibek and Malati Rai found themselves at the same Sakela festival in Jackson Heights, Queens. Ms. Rai performed a traditional dance at the event, a biannual celebration of nature and heritage for the Kirat Rai community of Nepal and Northeast India. The two spoke only briefly, then crossed paths again at another community event the following week. But it would be a few months before Mr. Rai formally asked her out.
“He’s a real gentleman,” said Ms. Rai, 31.
[Did you recently buy a home? We want to hear from you. Email: thehunt@nytimes.com. Sign up here to have The Hunt delivered to your inbox every week.]
Mr. Rai, a senior project manager with the city, was struck by Ms. Rai’s kindness. “That’s number one for me,” he said. “I care less about a lot of other things, but my top priority is you have to be a very nice person.”
The couple were both born and raised in Nepal. Mr. Rai, 38, arrived in New York nearly 20 years ago and earned bachelor’s and master’s degrees in civil engineering. Ms. Rai came about a decade ago, first for work in sales and marketing, and now in child care. During their courtship, Mr. Rai was renting a one-bedroom apartment in Woodside, while Ms. Rai lived with family in Jackson Heights.
“I always wanted to buy some property after I got married,” Ms. Rai said. “That was my thing.”
She shared her aspiration with Mr. Rai early in their relationship, and after the couple got married in 2024, she moved into his rental. “We were saving all the time, obviously,” Mr. Rai said.
They had started looking at homes before their wedding in Nepal, but between the travel and the cost of the celebration, the search had to take a back seat. About a year later, with a budget up to about $400,000, they started looking again. Ms. Rai wanted a place close to the subway so she could easily commute to Manhattan, while Mr. Rai wanted a short drive to his office in Long Island City. And they didn’t want to stray too far from their families and friends, who were mostly in Woodside, Sunnyside, Jackson Heights and Corona. Plus, they both loved the area.
“Jackson Heights offers a rare mix of city energy and almost village-like calm once you step off the main avenues,” Mr. Rai said. A two-bedroom was imperative, so they could make one bedroom into a nursery.
Focusing on co-op buildings, the couple partnered with Claudia Looi, an independent broker in Queens and Long Island. She started off by asking them to detail their entire financial profile. “You have to look at two major things for co-ops,” Ms. Looi said. “We have to know how much they make, also what kind of debt they have — student loans, car loans, the monthly maintenance and also the mortgage. Everything has to be calculated.”
The couple had no debt beyond Mr. Rai’s student loans, and those would be soon forgiven thanks to his employment with the city.
Among their options:
No. 1
Corner Unit in Jackson Heights
The two-bedroom, one-bath unit in a 1937 elevator building in Jackson Heights had about 750 square feet, with new vinyl plank floors, a big primary bedroom and space for a small eating table in the kitchen. The views were mostly of brick walls. The building offered a live-in super and basement laundry, and parking was available via a waitlist. A 7 train station was two avenues away, or about an eight-minute walk. The price was $370,000, with monthly maintenance of $824.
No. 2
Close to the Subway in Elmhurst
Two miles south, in Elmhurst, this two-bedroom, one-bath unit in a 1962 co-op had about 980 square feet, with a dated, eat-in kitchen that connected to a separate dining room. There were four big closets, including two in the primary bedroom, a foyer, and hardwood floors throughout. The building had a live-in super, a basement laundry room and an intercom system with Wi-Fi mobile access. The E, M, F and R lines were a block away. The price was $389,000, with monthly maintenance of $729.
No. 3
Carpeting and a Gym in Jackson Heights
This two-bedroom, one-bath unit in an elevator building in Jackson Heights had about 920 square feet. The front door opened into a long, open living-dining room covered in dated carpeting. A hallway separated the eat-in kitchen from the two bedrooms, which had hardwood floors. Building amenities included a laundry room, a courtyard with a playground, and a gym, which was a bonus for the couple. Bike storage and parking were available via a waitlist. The closest train line, the 7, was nearly a half mile away. The price was $378,000, with monthly maintenance of $740.
Find out what happened next by answering these two questions:
Which Would You Choose?
Corner Unit in Jackson Heights
Close to the Subway in Elmhurst
Carpeting and a Gym in Jackson Heights
Which Did They Buy?
Corner Unit in Jackson Heights
Close to the Subway in Elmhurst
Carpeting and a Gym in Jackson Heights